Nick Carbone

Reading with writing is better than reading with just a highlighter

Blog Post created by Nick Carbone Employee on Nov 13, 2015
do_not_highlight_mindlessly.jpg
Highlighting alone = ineffective learning

It's no longer a secret that highlighting alone (as opposed to highlighting as part of a note-taking strategy) is one of the least effective ways for students to learn. John Grohol, in an article that looks at research on effective student study strategies, pegs the findings on highlighting this way:

Indeed, students probably rely on tasks like highlighting and rereading because they are the easiest to do while actively studying. It’s so easy to whip out a highlighter and believe that by actively marking a passage, it’s somehow seeping into your brain cavities like syrup does into those little waffle compartments.

Sadly, that’s not the case. You might as well just sniff the highlighter for all the good highlighting does in helping you study.

 

However, writing as part of reading does lead to better reading comprehension and learning. In a 2010 Carnegie Corporation Report, “Writing to Read: Evidence for How Writing Can Improve Reading,” Steve Graham and Michael Hebert, after a review  of the research, write, “The evidence shows that having students write about the material they read does enhance their reading abilities. In fact, fifty-seven out of sixty-one outcomes (93 percent) were positive, indicating a consistent and positive effect for writing about what is read” (page 13).

 

So we can take two things from this research: one, writing while reading can help learning; two, it needs to be the right kind of writing done the right way (a.k.a summaries aren't right for all occasions).

 

In print, there are two common ways to write while reading: in the margins as annotations of the text being read, or writing outside of the text in a notebook (or reading journal, or research log, or index card, etc.), options that give readers more room for their thinking.

 

annotation_better.jpgtaking_notes.jpg
Classic annotation occurs in whatever space the margin allows.Notebooks give writers more room than margins.

 

Digital tools, like those found in LaunchPad, the Macmillan Learning platform the following images come from, combine margin annotations with a notebook's ability to write richer entries and add a third dimension: the option to share annotations and notes, turning them into discussions. Consider the following:

 

student_anno_highlight.jpg
A harmonious blend of highlighting, annotation, and note-taking.

As you can see in the image above, electronic tools combine the space of a notebook -- there's no limit to how much one can write -- with the margin location of an annotation. In the example above, the highlight draws attention to the part of the text the annotation/note responds to, putting the highlight in service of annotation and not just having it become unthoughtfully over-used.

 

The same tool can be used by the instructor to guide student responses, essentially turning the annotation tool into a shared annotations and notes, or, if preferred a discussion. By moving conversation to the margins of assigned text -- including text an instructor adds on their own -- it is easier to require students base comments and analysis on evidence from the text.  For novice readers, or readers encountering new ideas for the first time, seeing what others think, gleaning their take on texts, can create an experience similar to a study group or academic book club, as shown below.

 

 

group_annotation_instructor_start.jpg
When an instructor offers a prompt, students can reply to it and their annotations and notes can be shared.

By kicking off the kind of activity shown above, where students can reply to an instructor written note, instructors can do a number of things:

  • Write prompts that guide students to particular annotation strategies.
  • Foster rhetorical reading skills.
  • Use groups to set up study group discussions in text.
  • Allow students to see how classmates interpret or engage with assigned texts, fostering learning from classmates.

Outcomes